Gratitude is Bad for Your Heart

We hope you enjoy this research snack from the book Positivity by Barbara L. Fredrickson.
(Watch the Video)
When grateful words hide rage
This time of year we hear a lot about gratitude and giving thanks. As the holiday season cranks up, let’s be mindful of a type of gratitude that can backfire.
If you’ve been around Wild + Brave for a while, or you love positive psychology research like we do, you probably know research shows gratitude is like a superfood for your soul. Mind, body, spirit, when you experience gratitude, it has all kinds of good impacts on you.
But gratitude has a sort of evil twin.
In psychology, there’s a concept called “benefit finding” which entails verbalizing or acknowledging positive aspects of undesirable or challenging circumstances. For example, if you just totaled your car you could use benefit finding to remind yourself “at least my air bag and seat belt functioned well and I’m still healthy.” Or if you lost an important client, you might benefit-find by saying “now I’ll have more time to focus on my creative projects.”
The most common (and troublesome) benefit finding statement I hear is “other people have it much worse than I do.” It matters how we say this, and (most importantly) how we feel inside when we say this.
Choosing to identify good things in a bad situation is a skill, and like all skills, when we need it most we often are bad at it.

It takes practice to lift our focus off of what is wrong to find what is right. In that way, going through the motions to identify some “benefits” or positive implications of bad situation is just part of the process. It’s a good start. But if we force the gratitude for the “positive” out of our mouths before it gets into our hearts and lets us feel the good, we create new problems.
So beware: don’t confuse process of identifying potential positives with feeling gratitude.
Most of us have verbalized a positive statement that we didn’t feel. Technically, just identifying the words means we’ve succeeded at the psychological technique of “benefit finding.” But something happens in our bodies when we say things that don’t feel true.
In Positivity, the author references a study that shows our heart valves react to certain emotions — specifically anger and insincere gratitude — collapsing in response to micro moments of those specific emotions.
In other words, insincere gratitude has a negative biological impact on our physical hearts.
Pretty shocking since sincere gratitude has a heart-healthy impact on your nervous system and overall health. In Positivity the author links the insincere gratitude reaction with the concept of benefit finding and I find this helpful. On its own, reading an article about “insincere gratitude” sounds like a moral failing.
As in She said thank you but she didn’t really mean it.
But Fredrickson goes further, noticing the difference between whether “finding the positive” is life-giving or life-sapping based on whether or not you actually feel the positive impact of those factors.
I can acknowledge or admit I have many blessings…but if I allow myself to spew a litany of benefits, without feeling connected to the good, feeling joy in the good things, voicing them makes me feel even more alienated from the good in my life.
So today at Wild + Brave, we already know you’re bypassing performative gratitude. But chances are good there are some things in your life you tell yourself you should be grateful for. This year instead of forcing yourself to say those good things, take a pause.
Let your heart catch up to the good.
Don’t beat yourself over the head with it.
When you identify a good thing, a potentially-gratitude-worthy-thing, before you verbalize it, try to notice the good. Think into it, to let yourself visualize the implications, the value, the loveliness of the good. Warm the benefit up like a rock held in your palm.
Let your busy brain slow down, your heart open to experience the good. And once you feel it, only then you can say it.
PS: If feeling the positive emotion of gratitude is difficult for you, you’re not alone. There are a lot of factors that can block our access to these emotions. Bring your awareness to what you feel, and what feels blocked. Try to give yourself permission to sit with it, without judgment, and stay curious as you untangle and reconnect to your emotional responses.
More from the Blog on Gratitude
-
Activities + Exercises | Expand Energy + Focus | Find + Create Meaning for Life | Flourish Spiritually | Morgan Hendrix | Prevent + Solve Burnout | Relieve Anxiety + Stress | Video Blogs
Guided Gratitude Reflection – 5 Minute Journaling Exercise
Guided Gratitude Reflection Welcome to Wild + Brave, I’m coach Morgan. Today we’re doing a guided gratitude reflection. I’ll share some journaling prompts to prime your brain for noticing and savoring the things in your life that have made you stronger, healthier, happier, and more connected. Even writing down one answer to each question will…
-
Build Community + Culture | Find + Create Meaning for Life | Flourish Spiritually | Reflections of a Coach | Tinnitus Journal
After the Storm [Hurricane Ian 2022]
It’s been intimidating trying to capture the experiences of the storm we just weathered here in southwest Florida. The first hurricane I remember was Hurricane Andrew. My family lived in Fort Myers at the time, and our family businesses were on Sanibel Island. For Hurricane Andrew we closed up our little mom-and-pop style motels on…
-
Coaching + Helping People Grow | Expand Energy + Focus | Find + Create Meaning for Life | Flourish Spiritually | Grow Your Strengths | Morgan Hendrix | Prevent + Solve Burnout | Relieve Anxiety + Stress
Don’t Let Your Year-End Review Get Heavy
I think it’s because reflection is so valuable that we often fail to do it. In our desperate need for fresh insights, new motivation, and a sense of accomplishment, the reflection process looms larger than life. And if asking questions about our recent past begins to feel heavy, we delay doing it until we can “get it…
-
Stress Rescue Routine: E.A.S.E.
Stress doesn’t have to kill us. But sometimes we need a rescue from the chaos that has swallowed us. Learning how to respond well to stress allows us to stay energized enough to care for others, rather than being burnt out and irritable. It also allows us to work smarter and be more engaged and…
-
The No Goal Guide to Getting What You Want in 2018
At this time of year, we’re bombarded with goal setting ideas and strategies from EVERYWHERE! And they appeal to us because we all want more of something: more health, more positive relationships, more meaning, more financial security… We’re convinced that if we could just identify our goals, we’d be able to achieve them. But here’s…
-
Wild + Brave Thanksgiving Challenge
Whether you’ve got a big turkey dinner planned or not, chances are good you’re planning to do something to acknowledge the holiday tomorrow. And while it’s great that “Thanksgiving Day” gives us in the USA an annual excuse to stop and practice gratitude, it actually can become challenging not to let the day pass us by in busyness. While…
